Why do Doctor push on Tender Points in the Body?

Announcement

For those who missed the daily tips, blogs etc, sign up for the free ezine which will have the weeks tips and the blogs. Send an e-mail to fibro@drgenemartin.com, write ezine in the subject, and you’ll receive the ezine every Friday. I’ll need your full name. Also make sure your spam filter is not intercepting it.

The Tender Points that Doctors Press on

The fact is that using trigger or tender points as a way of trying to diagnosis Fibromyalgia was a good attempt at trying to find a diagnostic tool that just does not show up on any other diagnostic tests. However, many studies (the most recent being published in the fall of 2011) have shown that this is not a valid or reliable way of determining if a person has Fibromyalgia. However, I would like to explain why this test was first used and unfortunately many doctors are still using it to determine if a person has or does not have Fibromyalgia. This is unfortunate as many who do have Fibromyalgia are told that they don’t while some who do not have Fibromyalgia are told that they do.

Muscle metabolism is a complicated mechanism but in simplistic terms, the end product of muscle metabolism is lactic acid which is generally expelled by the body through the blood and than through the kidneys. When a person has Fibromyalgia, the muscles are in a constant state of contraction. The end product is a buildup of lactic acid being produced which the body cannot expel. The lactic acid then begins to accumulate in the muscle tissue which is very irritating and can damage this soft tissue. As a protective device, the body than produces fibrous tissue (think of cloth or other material), which covers the lactic acid, not allowing it to do further damage to the muscles. By the way, this is where the name Fibromyalgia comes from. Fibro means fibrous tissue, myo means muscle and algia means pain. Of course Fibromyalgia is a lot more than just muscle pain.

When a doctor is pushing on these 18 points (11 of 18 being tender was diagnostic), the doctor is irritating and sometimes breaking down the fibrous tissue leading to pain.

However, Lactic acid (and trigger points) can and are found in almost all people to some extent. For example, an athletic runner, running 5 miles per day will show these tender points. Many people after traumas of one type or another will also exhibit these points. We also live in a very stressful world and most of us are under stress on a daily basis, thus leading to these trigger points.

Dr. Janet Travell, M.D (now deceased) was considered the expert in trigger point mechanisms and trigger point therapy. She co-authored two books on the topic along with her co-author David Simon. Travell spent her career doing this type of research and was extremely well respected in the medical community. In fact she was the personal physician for Presidents John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson. She passed away at the age of 94 leaving a huge legacy of work related to trigger points. I suspect that if she was alive now, she would have plenty to say about using these tender points to diagnosis Fibromyalgia. Regardless, a thorough history is a better diagnostic method. Hopefully most doctors will catch up with the literature and realize that the tender point test is not a valid diagnostic criterion for Fibromyalgia.

Dr. Gene Martin

Fibromyalgia Relief Center of the Bay Area

520 South El Camino Real, Ste 520

San Mateo, Ca. 94402

650-558-1010

E-mail: fibro@drgenemartin.com

Web: http://www.nomorefibro.wordpress.com

Skype: dr.gene.martin

2 thoughts on “Why do Doctor push on Tender Points in the Body?

  1. Fortunately, only pressing on the tender points for diagnosis determination is only partial determination. History of pain and symptoms present are also included in the determination. It is my opinion that until we have a better way of diagnosis, the tender point portion of the diagnosis is the only thing keeping us apart from doctors believing we’re hypochondriacs.

    • The problem is that there are people with fibro who don’t have the tender points and there are non-fibro people who do. The best way to diagnosis it is with a thorough history by a doctor who understands fibro. The tender point test has been discredited again and again by numerous studies. The doctors who believe people to be hypochondriacs are ignorant and arrogant. Please read my blog on “Cultural Authority”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s